Middletown pastor blasts JD Vance’s hometown for silence in celebrating vice president-elect’s victory

J.D. Vance speaks at a rally in Middletown on July 22, 2024. MARSHALL GORBY, STAFF

Credit: Marshall Gorby

Credit: Marshall Gorby

J.D. Vance speaks at a rally in Middletown on July 22, 2024. MARSHALL GORBY, STAFF

A Middletown pastor blasted his hometown Tuesday night for not doing enough to recognize and celebrate Middletonian, U.S. Senator and Vice President-elect JD Vance, and for the city staying silent on his election win with President-elect Donald J. Trump.

Lamar Ferrell, pastor at Berachah Church, said the city celebrates many accomplishments from musicians to entrepreneurs, to athletes, “but we just have witnessed the election and no matter what side of the political party you sit on the reality is we have heard crickets from the city.”

A crowd arrived early to wait in the rain for a rally for Vice Presidential candidate J.D. Vance Monday, July 22, 2024 at Middletown High School. NICK GRAHAM/STAFF

icon to expand image

“JD Vance is a Middletonian ...before we debate and dialogue on what ‘Hillbilly Elegy’ has meant, JD has shown us all that we can all climb from a place that all of us would want to climb from,” Ferrell said.

In his best selling book “Hillbilly Elegy,” Vance was negative in describing Middletown and his upbringing in the city. Vance has been criticized by Middletown residents for comparing the city to his roots in Appalachia.

Ferrell, a 28-year Middletown resident, said he is proud to live in the city, but “the city has put a blanket” on Vance’s achievement by not mentioning “a word.”

Lamar Ferrell, pastor of Berachah Church in Middletown, has a security team that checks the parking lot and inside the church for potential dangerous intruders. RICK McCRABB / STAFF

icon to expand image

“Come on, Middletown we are better than this,” Ferrell said. “The reality is this: We have an opportunity to celebrate something that we have remained silent on ... Every accomplishment in the city we should applaud, whether we understand or agree with positions.”

Ferrell urged city council to stop the “nonsense of silence” and get their heads out of the sand.

“JD is a Middletonian. Proud to be a Middletonian. And I ask … what have we done about it?” he said.

Soon after election results were in on Nov. 5, Middletown City Schools posted an announcement that the 2003 grad was the vice president-elect, along with some historical facts. The city did not post anything on its website, but a congratulations message was posted on the Middletown Ohio Events Facebook page by Jeri Lewis, community projects coordinator.

Trump and Vance received around 62% of the vote in Middletown and Butler County.

At the meeting, Councilman Paul Lolli gave a shout out to the citizens of Middletown for turning out in force on election day, stating voter turnout was 61 percent in the city.

Lolli told the Journal-News, “I do think we should recognize the fact that the vice president will be from Middletown.”

Middletown native J.D. Vance announced his bid for U.S. Senate during an event at Middletown Tube Works with over 400 people in attendance Thursday, July 1, 2021 in Middletown. NICK GRAHAM / STAFF

Credit: Nick Graham

icon to expand image

Credit: Nick Graham

He is all for a sign to be placed at the entry of the city as “the home of the vice president. It should be celebrated regardless of your political beliefs,”

Councilman Steve West II said, “In this town we don’t celebrate enough. I am saddened that we really don’t celebrate all of Middletown’s wins.”

On a recent out-of-state trip, West said mentioning he lives where Vance is from opened up a whole dialogue about the city.

West said he does believe some acknowledgment should have been posted.

“You don’t have to agree with his stance or policies, but just acknowledge and recognize that this serves as a great example that anybody that grows up here in Middletown, you can become anything. That is the real message.”

JD Vance speaks to media after voting with his wife and kids in Cincinnati. NICK GRAHAM/STAFF

icon to expand image

During the meeting, councilwoman Jennifer Carter gave a quote of inspiration from her pastor: “’What you ignore becomes more, what you tolerate will soon take over, what you challenge will change.’ I am hoping that Middletown will grasp this and run with it.”

Carter told the Journal-News that she planned to use the quote without any knowledge that Ferrell would be at the meeting.

Acting City Manger Nathan Cahall told the Journal-News the city is working on an article for the city’s winter newsletter about how Vance’s candidacy and election have shined a wide-reaching spotlight on the city.

About the Author